Accessibility Widget: On | Off

Light Bicycle Heavy Duty Carbon Rim

Views:
Vital Rating: (Outstanding)
Create New Tag

Need more info? View our MTB Rims buyer's guides.

Do Cheap Chinese Carbon Wheels Last? Two Years of Abuse on Light Bicycle's Carbon Rims

Saving thousands of dollars sounded very appealing, so we bought a pair of $181 carbon rims on our own dime and mounted them to a downhill bike. To our surprise, they're still running strong.

Rating: Vital Review

As the banter increases around 29-inch wheels in downhill, we've decided to throw it back to 26-inch days and offer up a very long-term review of Light Bicycle's Heavy Duty Carbon rims designed for downhill and enduro use. With key players like ENVE, Industry Nine, e*thirteen, SRAM, Reynolds and others holding the majority of the carbon wheel market, Light Bicycle has been building steam over the years by creating a price point rim they claim performs like the big names at the fraction of the price. At just $181 per rim, we decided to purchase and abuse a set of rims to see how they would hold up to the others. Grab a beverage and we'll get to it!

Carbon Wheel Basics

Before venturing into specifics, let's address some basics about carbon wheels in general. The first question most riders ask is, "Will a $3,000+ wheelset really make that big of a difference? Is it really worth it?" This depends on a few criteria, mostly based around your experience as a rider and what you're looking for in a wheelset that you may not be getting with your current wheels.

You will notice the most difference if you're a skilled rider who likes to charge lines and are generally aggressive with your bike. Carbon rims are laterally stiffer than aluminum and therefore decrease flex of the wheel in a corner, etc. As a result, many carbon wheels are characterized by a harsher but more precise ride, so if you're looking for comfort in your wheelset carbon may not be the right option for you. This wheel feel is often desired among racers and others looking to make up seconds, so the tradeoff is worth it to them.

Photo

Wheel and frame stiffness play a big role in taking the forces you apply at the handlebars / pedals and ultimately directing them to the tire to generate traction and control. The bigger the wheel diameter, the harder it is to keep stiff. Of course it's possible to go too stiff, so there's a balance needed in a carbon wheelset between compliance and stiffness. A wheel of any material needs to flex to a certain extent. This is where high performance carbon wheel testing has proven that a stiffer wheel may be more powerful, but a compliant wheel will stay on the ground, deflect less, and provide better traction. Another argument is having "give" where you need it to eliminate the common issue of overly stiff wheels exploding rather than flexing.

The move to carbon can also aid with quicker acceleration due to less rotating weight. These are the main differences in carbon wheels and they can be substantial. This brings us back to our product at hand, the Light Bicycle Heavy Duty Carbon rim.

Photo

Highlights

  • Full carbon Toray T700 rim material with hookless profile and beadlock
  • Available in 26 (tested), 27.5, and 29-inch sizes
  • Designed for downhill, enduro, and freeride use
  • Internal width: 31.6mm // External width: 38mm // Depth: 32mm
  • Tubeless ready (tape and valve optional)
  • 16, 18, 20, 24, 28, 32 (tested), or 36 spoke holes
  • Max rider weight: 26" - 342lbs (155kg) // 27.5", 29" - 308lbs (140kg)
  • Max tire pressure: 40psi
  • Max spoke tension: 180kgf
  • 3k, 12k, and UD weave options (rim strength and weight are virtually identical)
  • Matte or glossy finish
  • One year warranty
  • Weight: 26" - 485g // 27.5" - 505g // 29" - 515g
  • MSRP: $181-193 per rim

This is Light Bicycle's widest (38mm outer, 31.6mm inner) and tallest (32mm) profile made for aggressive use, and the stiffest and strongest as well. It's offered in both all-mountain and heavy duty versions, and this review focuses on the burlier of the two.

Compared to their previous model they have improved the current one by using a hookless rim profile. This increases strength. There are "beadlock ridges" on either side of the drop channel to help reduce the possibility of a tire rolling off or air burping.

Photo

One benefit to the wide profile is improved tire sidewall support, which allows for lower pressures to be run without burping. There's a balance in tire pressure and rim width – too much or too little pressure can decrease rolling speed and traction.

After their first couple years in the industry and many months of testing, Light Bicycle decided to overhaul the manufacturing process. "During the redesign, we focused on five main improvements: carbon length/layup, carbon base ring removal, air bladder removal, internal uniformity improvement, and enhanced testing protocols." From what we've read in other reviews and forums, this overhaul seemed to solve prior manufacturing defects the company had.

Photo
Photo
Photo

Light Bicycle allows you to choose from three carbon weaves, two finishes, and seven decal colors to customize the look of your rims. The layup schedule is predetermined for each model, but you can choose the outer weave layer. There are also an impressive seven hole counts to choose from, allowing you to create some truly unique wheels if you choose. We opted for the matte UD option with stealth graphics, which have been updated since the time of purchase over two years ago.

Light Bicycle offers a custom build program with similar components, and the total cost of the wheelset would run close to $856 with valves and tape with a claimed weight of 1,833g.

The 26-inch rims we tested come in at a claimed 485g per rim, which is comparable to many market leaders. We built them up using Hope Technology's Pro 2 Evo hubs and straight-gauge DT Swiss spokes. Light Bicycle offers a custom build program with similar components, and the total cost of the wheelset would run close to $856 with valves and tape with a claimed weight of 1,833g.

On The Trail

How do all these improvements and dorking out actually pertain to the riding experience? Having the time to carry out a proper long-term test allowed us to see how these wheels performed in various locations and different conditions. We were able to ride gnarly, rocky, muddy trails in Colorado's Rocky Mountains as well as moon dust, fast, and loose conditions in the same areas. California offered typical terrain and some of the driest conditions we saw last season. We also spent time smashing through Angel Fire, New Mexico's lava gardens and some truly rugged trails in Utah, giving us a multitude of terrain to test on. We weren't disappointed.

Photo

Just as expected, the wheels felt stiff, responsive, and very quick at regaining speed when it was lost. Cornering was improved greatly and exit speeds were increased due to not losing momentum where a typical aluminum wheel would flex. We also noticed a harsher ride, yet a small change in tire pressure and decrease in compression in the suspension allowed the wheel to do its job and decrease the harshness as well.

Cornering was improved greatly and exit speeds were increased due to not losing momentum where a typical aluminum wheel would flex. We also noticed a harsher ride, yet a small change in tire pressure and decrease in compression in the suspension allowed the wheel to do its job and decrease the harshness as well.

Once everything was dialed in we noticed the wheels dissipated typically chundery and bumpy terrain. We were able to take more aggressive lines and the bike was able to keep traction better as the wheel held true at high speeds, especially in corners. When pumping and pushing we also noticed improved acceleration and the bike felt much more responsive and playful.

Photo
Photo

We've ridden this wheelset for almost two years, being mindful to adjust tire pressures before riding. Compared to others we've tested there are some notable improvements. As long as we paid attention to maintenance of the wheel, including spoke tension, we hardly had to mess with any truing. The rim has not cracked, broken, or delaminated. We've worn out three sets of tires while testing and didn't have ANY burps or tires rolling off despite several marks on the wheel from entering rocky sections at full speed.

As long as we paid attention to maintenance of the wheel, including spoke tension, we hardly had to mess with any truing. The rim has not cracked, broken, or delaminated.

Things That Could Be Improved

This brings us to things that could be improved, which is usually easy enough to distinguish with past reviews of carbon rims simply cracking or breaking. We had zero problems with the structure of the rim. They are wider and deeper than other large competitors and comparable in the weight game. Compared to other brands that offer five year or lifetime warranties, Light Bicycle offers just one year of coverage.

Photo

Long Term Durability

These rims have proven themselves in the durability department by lasting much longer than other carbon rims we've tested.

If you decide to purchase just the rims, using a professional wheel builder with carbon-specific experience will help ensure the strongest wheels due to specific spoke tension requirements. Careful hub and spoke selection is also key, as they are not created equally and you will get what you pay for.

Photo
Photo

The addition of Hope's Pro 2 Evo hubs kept our test wheels rolling fast and smooth with sealed stainless steel bearings. The hub shells are machined from forged aluminum billet and have excellent reliability. The engagement and sound of the rear hub is also amazing with a 4-pawl system featuring 40 points of engagement at 9-degrees.

The other caveat we'd like to revisit since the beginning of this review is wheel size. The bigger the wheel, the harder it is to keep strong. We tested 26-inch rims and they took a serious, long-term beating without breaking. This speaks well for Light Bicycles 27.5 and 29-inch versions, though we can't vouch for them without an additional test.

Photo

What's The Bottom Line?

Carbon rims have the potential to increase the performance of any bike, and riders with a good amount of experience and skill are most likely to notice the various benefits. At the relatively "cheap" cost of $181 per carbon rim, Light Bicycle's Heavy Duty rims offer notable performance gains for a small price jump compared to a nice aluminum rim.

Based on our positive experience we can suggest giving these rims a go, especially if you've been on the fence about carbon. They're also a good option for those who've experienced issues with more expensive rims and want to try again with one that won't break the bank. Paying attention to small details like the wheel build, tire pressure, and spoke tension will make your investment last longer.

Visit www.lightbicycle.com for more details.


About The Reviewer

Matt Swenson - Age: 34 // Years Riding MTB: 27 // Height: 5'11" (1.80m) // Weight: 160-pounds (72.6kg)

He's a ColoRADo native who's been shredding bikes since the age of two and his life revolves around two wheels. He currently works at Winter Park Resort running both the Gravity and XC race series, as well as a new Junior Development Race Program at Trestle Bike Park. He's worked in the medical field but has also built and judged slopestyle events like GoPro/Teva Games, the Colorado Freeride Festival, Crankworx and others. Growing up working in bike shops as a mechanic, he's always been a nerd when it comes to bike components and tech. These days he enjoys the bike park, trail riding, skatepark and dirt jump sessions with his wife and puppy. He's always down to shred a lap at Trestle Bike Park, so don't be afraid to say hi! "Hold the throttle wide open ‘til you see God...then brake."

Photos by Dillon Lemarr

Rate review:

26 comments newest first

I've been on LB wheels since 2012 and they're all still going strong. I have a set of 33's, (the oldest and lightest, 1430g) a set of 38's, 1530g) and now a set of 46's, (40i) for my 26+ wheelset. The first 2 are built with Hopes and DT Supercomps and the plus wheelset is with Onyx and DT Aerolight's. Best wheelsets I've owned and the single best improvement to the bike. I would never go back to alloy.

| Reply

There is an error in the article too, 38mm is not the widest rim that LB makes, they make 46mm, (40i) rims for 26+ tires, (what I’m currently running). Also, I’m not sure why the weight of their test rims are 485g for the 38mm (32i) 26” rim. Mine are 420g each and my 40i rims are 450g. They must have gotten the DH layup. 40i rim link,
https://www.lightbicycle.com/Carbon-beadless-46mm-wide-26-inch-plus-rim-for-more-traction-tubeless-compatible.html

| Reply

I still hear people say "cheap, Chinese crap", but, to paraphrase Forrest Gump's mother, "crap is as crap does". If inexpensive rims can be lighter, wider, and stronger, then maybe they're not crap.

The harshness issue can be partially addressed through thinner spokes. Thin, butted spokes (ex. 2.0-1.5-2.0 mm) not only feel a touch softer, they also improve the durability of the nipples and rims. If more strength is required, use a higher spoke count, rather than thicker spokes.

| Reply

I had two LB rims on my XC bike. Cracked the rear on the third ride. Cracked the front a year later. Now I'm running "name brand" carbon rims and when you compare them to the LB rims, it's very clear that the LB rims are thin and weak... especially the bead. That sad, I've also cracked two of the "name brand" carbon rims. Not worth it. I'm going back to alu rims.

| Reply

Looks good. Might buy some when I have lots of money for good hubs, and spokes. On the other hand I literally just bought my rear rim, and I ride like a old grandpa, so we'll have to see, no point pumping money into the ground. Might also stick to aluminum, in my mind I'd rather have high end aluminum than low end carbon, not really a weight weenie, and I'm skeptical when people are saying they're breaking carbon fibre, when everyone always says 1000 times stronger, and 5 times lighter than steel. It makes you wonder.

| Reply

I've been riding the 27.5 variant of these rims for nearly 2 years as well in Oregon, and Northern California. Aside from some scuffs and love marks these wheels have been stiff and precise with no failure or issues of any kind. I'm thrilled with Light Bicycle's quality product and if I ever do need a replacement LB's at the top of the list. Yes they're more expensive than very capable alloy competition, but for light and durable carbon wheels they're an absolute bargain.

| Reply

Used these for a season in Whistler riding almost everyday. Finished about 500 laps, + Crankworx races, phat Wednesdays, and did a few BC cups.

They felt awesome to ride, I never had one flat or burp all season and was running pretty low tire pressures. Super solid, quick turning and predictable. (they were with 2.25 Magic mary's on 27.5)

I did crack 3 rims throughout the season, and they replaced all free of charge (i just had to pay shipping). I ended up buying a third as a spare as the turn around was ~2 weeks.

I have since sold that bike, but am pretty keen to get a set again for my trail bike!

| Reply

So to keep riding, you have to buy 3 rims...so $180 x 3 = $540 in rims to keep you riding?

How much money would you have gone through with aluminum rims assuming your typical amount of expense for the aluminum rims for the same amount if time as you spent on the carbon?

| Reply

I only bought a spare to take to races with me. That way if I broke a wheel I would have a spare with me.

I ended up using a DT fr570 wheelset for much longer than the carbon ones lasted. They were running great. But I preferred the feel of the carbons

In one of the warranty downtimes (2 weeks) I managed to bang up an alloy rim pretty good in that period buit it was still rideable with a tube.

| Reply

Been running LB wheels for almost 4yrs now, never a single issue or repair/claim

| Reply

The big question, so in the end, what's the reason why other carbon rim manufacturers charge $3,000? A sticker that says ENVE costs $2,200 to produce?

| Reply

Somebody has to pay Greg Minnaars salary....

Seriously though. Race teams, R and D, marketing etc don't come cheap.

| Reply

It depends on the manufacturer. I know for a fact that LB produces several of the popular carbon wheels that are out there today. Enve does have to deal with the EPA, but I doubt that is $600 per rim in expense and Enve must have been very profitable for the amount of money they got in the buyout.

| Reply

Would this be a compelling choice over a substantially cheaper yet slightly narrower and slightly heavier aluminum rim like the Stan's ZTR Flow Mk 3?

| Reply

there are plenty of aluminum options out there with good width that are equal to or lighter than these and most other carbon rims. you can go buy some Spank Oozy Trail 295's at 450g per rim (30gs lighter) for half the price. my 27.5" wheelset of the same variety were 80 grams less than these 26"s, for $500. ive had this discussion a few times recently with some homies who are testers for a big mag, their consensus is that the ALU wheels they are testing now have come so far in the past few years that Carbon is getting harder to justify if you have to pay full retail. not a carbon hater, most of my bike is plastic, but I'm too hard on wheels for anything but metal. also seems like everyone is running Cushcore on their carbon hoops for flat insurance these days, which is pushing their wheel weight well above almost any ALU rim....

| Reply

It really depends on what you're looking for. Obviously there's the price to consider. Carbon rims can be stiffer, lighter, and wider, but it's generally going to cost you a lot more. Aluminum can offer other advantages as well, though.

For one, alloy rims are more likely to bend instead of crack if they get damaged, and you can often bend them back into shape and/or re-true them and keep riding unlike with a cracked carbon rim. Plus the Stan's rims are much more readily available if you do manage to completely destroy one. You'd probably have to wait at least a week or two if not longer for a replacement from one of these cheap Chinese manufacturers.

The fact that aluminum will typically provide a little more compliance can often be a good thing too depending on what you want. Perhaps aluminum rims would be a better option if you're building up a hardtail for example.

If you don't have a tendency to destroy rims and you can afford the higher price, then I'd say yes it is a compelling option. But ultimately you have to weigh your priorities and make that decision for yourself.

| Reply

Yeah, that's a good point. I forgot about that. Although I believe they only stock a subset of the rims they offer, so depending on which custom options you choose, that may or may not be an option.

| Reply

I have had a set of their 27.5 rims on my enduro bike for 2 years now. they have taken quite a beating, and are still holding strong, definitely don't regret the purchase. they have seen lots of square edge hits, jumps and general rowdiness/abuse, especially in and around golden/revy in canada.

My buddy who ordered them at the same time in the same order managed to break one within a couple weeks.

I still think its a crapshoot in terms of durability, but that can be said about any product really. The shop i work at has seen plenty of the big name brand carbon wheels get warrantied as well.

| Reply

I've been bashing two sets of the 38mm 27.5 one set hd other set am for around 2 years with no problems at all their bomb proof as far as carbon rims go even the am version survived rim dinger at bpw on a number of occasions that speaks volumes alone 10/10 from me it's a no brainier

| Reply

glad someone finally gave LB the review they deserved. I had a great experience with a set I had before changing wheel sizes and abandoning those wheels. Setting up tubeless was definitely difficult for me.

I did witness someone crack one at trestle this past weekend but it wasnt a catastrophic failure.

| Reply
Show More Comment(s)
Specifications
Product Light Bicycle Heavy Duty Carbon Rim
Riding Type Downhill, Freeride / Bike Park
Wheel Size 26", 27.5" (650b), 29"
Material Carbon
Material Details Full Carbon Toray T700
Tubeless Compatible Yes
Joint N/A
Holes 16, 18, 20, 24, 28, 32, or 36
Inner Rim Width 31.6mm
ERD 511, 536, 574mm
Colors Glossy or Matte Black // 12K, 3K, or UD Weave
Weight
  • 1 lb 1.1 oz (485 g)
  • 1 lb 1.8 oz (505 g)
  • 1 lb 2.2 oz (515 g)
Miscellaneous Outer width - 38mm
Depth - 32mm
Max weight limit - 26-inch: 342lbs (155kg) // 650B, 29-inch: 308lbs (140kg)
Max spoke tension - 180kgf
Max tire pressure - 40psi
Price
  • $181
  • $188
  • $193
More Info

​Light Bicycle website

What do you think?
Photo Manager | Double-click to insert a photo | Insert Photo Group

Choose Layout

2-stack Images
3-stack Images
4-stack Images
Add Photos
Your rating:
  • Five stars
  • Four and a half stars
  • Four stars
  • Three and a half stars
  • Three stars
  • Two and a half stars
  • Two stars
  • One and a half stars
  • One star

More Products