The fastest mountain bikers in the world attacked the brutal, steep World Cup Downhill course in Italy for the final qualification round of 2015. When the dust settled and the rocks stopped rolling, Troy Brosnan, Rachel Atherton and Alex Marin came out on top.
Notes
- Troy and Gwin only .168 apart.
- After Loic who was just off in 3rd place, the rest of the field falls off significantly.
- We're gettingย a report that Brook MacDonald dislocated his knee. Not confirmed, but bummer if true and he still managed 11th somehow.
- Mike Jones is a DNF, but he's a protected Top 20 rider, so he will be allowed to race.
- The Top 3 Women are really close.
- The Junior battle is tight as always.
Elite Men's Qualifying Results
1 | BROSNAN Troy | AUS19930713 | SPECIALIZED RACING | 3:33.934 |
2 | GWIN Aaron | USA19871224 | SPECIALIZED RACING | +0.168 |
3 | BRUNI Loic | FRA19940513 | LAPIERRE GRAVITY REPUBLIC | +1.336 |
4 | MINNAAR Greg | RSA19811113 |
| +4.016 |
5 | ATHERTON Gee | GBR19850226 | GT FACTORY RACING | +4.673 |
6 | HART Danny | GBR19910920 | MS MONDRAKER TEAM | +5.063 |
7 | BLENKINSOP Samuel | NZL19881028 | NORCO FACTORY RACING | +6.114 |
8 | BRYCELAND Josh | GBR19900323 |
| +8.531 |
9 | BRANNIGAN George | NZL19920409 | TREK WORLD RACING | +9.092 |
10 | GUTIERREZ VILLEGAS Marcelo | COL19900509 | GIANT FACTORY OFF-ROAD TEAM | +9.206 |
11 | MACDONALD Brook | NZL19911125 | TREK WORLD RACING | +9.677 |
12 | SMITH Steve | CAN19891125 | DEVINCI GLOBAL RACING | +10.560 |
13 | WALLACE Mark | CAN19950601 | DEVINCI GLOBAL RACING | +10.913 |
14 | FEARON Connor | AUS19940119 | KONA FACTORY TEAM | +11.069 |
15 | LUCAS Dean | AUS19950502 | DEVINCI GLOBAL RACING | +11.308 |
16 | VERGIER Loris | FRA19960507 | LAPIERRE GRAVITY REPUBLIC | +11.503 |
17 | SIMMONDS Matthew | GBR19870520 | MADISON SARACEN FACTORY TEAM | +11.519 |
18 | THOME Patrick | FRA19911020 | CK RACING | +12.067 |
19 | PAULHAN Romain | FRA19880416 | KONA - X1 RACING | +12.386 |
20 | TRUMMER David | AUT19940601 | GHOST RRP | +13.002 |
21 | FAIRCLOUGH Brendan | GBR19880110 | GSTAAD-SCOTT | +13.095 |
22 | KERR Bernard | GBR19910216 | PIVOT FACTORY DH TEAM | +13.649 |
23 | MASTERS Edward | NZL19890818 | BERGAMONT HAYES COMPONENTS FACTORY TEAM | +13.667 |
24 | PEKOLL Markus | AUT19871013 | MS MONDRAKER TEAM | +13.909 |
25 | HEATH Harry | GBR19910805 | NORCO FACTORY RACING | +13.937 |
26 | WILLIAMSON Greg | GBR19920608 | TREK WORLD RACING | +13.953 |
27 | FIGARET Faustin | FRA19931107 | CALVISSON VTT | +14.122 |
28 | SHAW Luca | USA19961225 | SRAM/TLD RACING | +14.149 |
29 | MULALLY Neko | USA19930219 | GSTAAD-SCOTT | +14.252 |
30 | VERNON Taylor | GBR19960912 | GT FACTORY RACING | +14.355 |
31 | COULANGES Benoit | FRA19941220 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | +14.582 |
32 | PIERRON Baptiste | FRA19930808 |
| +15.019 |
33 | BEER Matthew | CAN19860926 |
| +15.296 |
34 | MASTERS Wyn | NZL19870418 | TEAM BULLS - DH | +15.522 |
35 | ZABJEK Jure | SLO19951011 | UNIOR TOOLS TEAM | +15.848 |
36 | CUNNINGHAM Ruaridh | GBR19890215 | UNIOR TOOLS TEAM | +16.070 |
37 | GALLAGHER Kenta | GBR19920622 |
| +16.298 |
38 | FISCHBACH Johannes | GER19880304 | GHOST RRP | +16.338 |
39 | FAYOLLE Alexandre | FRA19950720 |
| +16.575 |
40 | CHAPMAN Rupert | NZL19920409 | BERGAMONT HAYES COMPONENTS FACTORY TEAM | +17.104 |
41 | WALKER Matthew | NZL19900324 |
| +17.222 |
42 | BEER Nick | SUI19870917 | RADON MAGURA FACTORY | +17.482 |
43 | WILSON Reece | GBR19960611 | UNIOR TOOLS TEAM | +17.650 |
44 | VERNASSA Gianluca | ITA19950904 | AB DEVINCI ITALY | +17.671 |
45 | LEVESQUE Dylan | FRA19961009 |
| +18.023 |
46 | MOLLOY Harry | GBR19910530 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +18.251 |
47 | COLOMBO Francesco | ITA19951209 | AB DEVINCI ITALY | +18.375 |
48 | GUARDIA PASCUAL Bernat | ESP19820930 | INTENSE FACTORY RACING | +18.507 |
49 | READING Jack | GBR19881210 | ONE VISION GLOBAL RACING | +18.607 |
50 | PIERRON Amaury | FRA19960304 | LAC BLANC SCOTT | +19.171 |
51 | BARTH Joshua | GER19950616 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +19.416 |
52 | GARLICKI Stefan | RSA19900912 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +19.558 |
53 | ATWILL Philip | GBR19950111 | ORANGE DIRT WORLD TEAM, XFUSION | +19.756 |
54 | PANDUR Ziga | SLO19910117 | UNIOR TOOLS TEAM | +19.829 |
55 | DAVIES Emyr | GBR19900315 |
| +19.834 |
56 | SUAREZ ALONSO Angel | ESP19951202 |
| +19.949 |
57 | GANNICOTT George | GBR19950311 |
| +19.969 |
58 | ACUNA QUINTANA Mauricio Andres | CHI19880815 |
| +20.007 |
59 | CAUVIN Guillaume | FRA19940521 | GIANT FACTORY OFF-ROAD TEAM | +20.167 |
60 | CHAPUIS Maxime | SUI19941222 |
| +20.224 |
61 | BARANEK Rastislav | SVK19950414 |
| +20.413 |
62 | DALE Sam | GBR19900212 | MADISON SARACEN FACTORY TEAM | +20.432 |
63 | CAIRE Carlo | ITA19940804 | AB DEVINCI ITALY | +20.530 |
64 | GEORGES Pierre Charles | FRA19860206 | LAC BLANC SCOTT | +20.608 |
65 | WILLIAMSON Jay | GBR19930506 | STEVE PEAT SYNDICATE GLOBAL | +20.611 |
66 | RIESCO Forrest | CAN19940124 |
| +20.666 |
67 | BRAYTON Adam | GBR19881019 |
| +20.721 |
68 | HILL Samuel | AUS19850721 | CHAIN REACTION CYCLES / PAYPAL | +20.769 |
69 | STRASSER Benny | GER19890805 | RADON MAGURA FACTORY | +20.990 |
70 | PONS Melvin | FRA19940805 |
| +20.998 |
71 | WEBER Lutz | SUI19921204 | SWISS DOWNHILL SYNDICATE | +21.463 |
72 | RACAUD Felix | FRA19950111 |
| +21.629 |
73 | COMETTI Luca | USA19951208 | INTENSE FACTORY RACING | +21.761 |
74 | JOHANSEN Zakarias Blom | NOR19921125 |
| +22.020 |
75 | SMITH Joseph | GBR19900704 | CHAIN REACTION CYCLES / PAYPAL | +22.029 |
76 | HANNAH Michael | AUS19831121 | POLYGON UR | +22.120 |
77 | JAUCH Jasper | GER19910721 |
| +22.425 |
78 | LUKASIK Slawomir | POL19930501 |
| +22.427 |
79 | POMBO Emanuel | POR19870616 |
| +22.672 |
80 | CARBALLO GONZALEZ Edgar | ESP19881222 |
| +22.819 |
81 | BUISAN Geoffrey | FRA19940518 |
| +22.825 |
82 | MEDICI Simone | ITA19950705 |
| +22.849 |
83 | JACKSON Eliot | USA19900619 | PIVOT FACTORY DH TEAM | +22.943 |
84 | VAUH Miran | SLO19821104 |
| +23.134 |
85 | ESTAQUE Thomas | FRA19961115 | LAC BLANC SCOTT | +23.405 |
86 | NEVES CRUZ Bernardo | BRA19910416 |
| +23.577 |
87 | MCGLONE Fraser | GBR19940531 |
| +24.479 |
88 | RUFFIN Gaetan | FRA19910629 | COMMENCAL / VALLNORD | +24.628 |
89 | DI PASQUALE Charly | FRA19900704 |
| +24.668 |
90 | SEHNAL Stanislav | CZE19940609 | BANSHEE BIKES FACTORY TEAM | +24.734 |
91 | BOUVET Jacques | GER19940806 | TEAM BULLS - DH | +24.920 |
92 | ONDIC Jozef | SVK19960807 |
| +25.131 |
93 | LEIVSSON Isak | NOR19931017 |
| +25.231 |
94 | LOWE Josh | GBR19941116 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +25.239 |
95 | NIEDERBERGER Noel | SUI19950821 | SWISS DOWNHILL SYNDICATE | +25.413 |
96 | CAROLI Jerome | SUI19951126 |
| +25.550 |
97 | CHANUDET Quentin | FRA19920927 |
| +25.572 |
98 | NEUFFER Marius | GER19950821 |
| +25.756 |
99 | STUTTARD Mathew | GBR19930604 | TWOTWO GRAVITY RACING | +25.916 |
100 | KOLB Andreas | AUT19960323 |
| +26.733 |
101 | ROMERO PERICH Pol | ESP19910518 |
| +27.246 |
102 | JORBA PRATS Guillem | ESP19940319 |
| +27.339 |
103 | CONNELL Joseph | GBR19940320 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +27.780 |
104 | PAZDZIORKO Gregoire | BEL19950328 |
| +27.944 |
105 | FREI Martin | SUI19880730 |
| +28.005 |
106 | KLEE Felix | SUI19941003 |
| +28.423 |
107 | DICKERSON Bryn | NZL19911015 |
| +28.962 |
108 | BULL Samuel | RSA19940322 |
| +29.122 |
109 | ORTIZ VASQUEZ Gustavo | CHI19951012 |
| +29.431 |
110 | ILES Jack | CAN19961007 | NORCO FACTORY RACING | +29.804 |
111 | JUNYENT TRASERRA Jordi | ESP19930225 |
| +29.861 |
112 | PETRUCCI Francesco Danilo | ITA19911112 |
| +29.913 |
113 | HERD Sam | GBR19960118 |
| +30.234 |
114 | LAMB Fergus | GBR19850916 |
| +30.325 |
114 | MEZZETTA Stefano | ITA19940128 |
| +30.325 |
116 | IRMISCH Erik | GER19880913 |
| +30.657 |
117 | RICHARDS Shaun | GBR19960104 |
| +30.776 |
118 | WILLIAMS Peter | GBR19881117 | ONE VISION GLOBAL RACING | +30.988 |
119 | DENGATE Benjamin | AUS19960908 |
| +31.206 |
120 | GUIJARRO VILLACIEROS Javier | ESP19910509 |
| +31.893 |
121 | ETXEBARRIA Iraitz | ESP19910813 |
| +32.476 |
122 | PEAT Steve | GBR19740617 |
| +32.508 |
123 | EVANS Craig | GBR19910216 |
| +32.832 |
124 | BUCHANAN Lewis | GBR19930927 | BANSHEE BIKES FACTORY TEAM | +33.511 |
125 | ENGEL Pascal | AUT19960622 |
| +34.752 |
126 | BLAIR Lachlan | GBR19951013 |
| +34.768 |
127 | MCCORKELL Matthew | AUS19961229 |
| +35.950 |
128 | BERNET Jonas | SUI19940218 |
| +35.980 |
129 | SCHNETTLER Christoph Felix | GER19920214 |
| +36.843 |
130 | MEARS Scott | GBR19890206 |
| +37.712 |
131 | RUFFIN Thibaut | FRA19841030 | COMMENCAL / VALLNORD | +38.481 |
132 | MALY Petr | CZE19951023 |
| +38.496 |
133 | BREWIN Gareth | GBR19910623 |
| +38.706 |
134 | CARTERS Drew | GBR19960226 |
| +39.754 |
135 | SUDING Lorenzo | ITA19860315 | EXCEPTIO SPORT - COMMENCAL | +39.986 |
136 | LIVORTI Gionata | ITA19931117 |
| +40.034 |
137 | BEGGIN Alan | ITA19850324 |
| +41.409 |
138 | IVANCIC Miha | SLO19960324 |
| +41.922 |
139 | TINNER Pascal | SUI19910108 | SWISS DOWNHILL SYNDICATE | +45.471 |
140 | OLARRA LOPEZ Daniel | ESP19960504 |
| +48.655 |
141 | BARON James | NZL19841213 |
| +50.324 |
142 | SCERBININS Marcis | LAT19810320 |
| +50.383 |
143 | VILNIS Renars | LAT19960721 |
| +53.252 |
144 | PLANITZER Markus | AUT19900521 |
| +55.921 |
145 | LETH Frederik Andersen | DEN19950124 |
| +58.467 |
146 | CASAL VALLS Guillem | AND19950925 |
| +1:02.814 |
147 | SCHLEGEL Jens | GER19881010 |
| +1:05.560 |
148 | TINNER Dominic | SUI19940116 | SWISS DOWNHILL SYNDICATE | +1:12.883 |
149 | RUSANOV Andrey | RUS19890720 |
| +1:27.582 |
150 | PUKHIR Nikolay | RUS19880224 |
| +1:42.939 |
151 | KAGAROV Saken | KAZ19940221 |
| +1:44.288 |
152 | LARBEYOU Guillaume | FRA19940915 |
| +2:34.852 |
153 | JOUET PASTRE Martin | FRA19950521 |
| +2:46.887 |
154 | CEPELAK Jan | CZE19940702 |
| +2:47.372 |
155 | SERENO Pedro | VEN19880902 |
| +3:13.654 |
156 | MILANI Mario | ITA19931114 |
| +5:53.785 |
| JONES Michael | GBR19950222 | CHAIN REACTION CYCLES / PAYPAL | DNF |
| DAVIES Jarrah | AUS19890507 |
| DNF |
| FERREIRO PAJUELO Antonio | ESP19900103 |
| DNS |
| HANSSON Marcus | SWE19960429 | EXCEPTIO SPORT - COMMENCAL | DNS |
| VARLEY Aiden | AUS19960816 |
| DNS |
| KHRIPUNOV Vitaly | RUS19960223 |
| DNS |
| PALAZZARI Davide | ITA19950619 |
| DNS |
Elite Women's Qualifying Results
1 | ATHERTON Rachel | GBR19871206 | GT FACTORY RACING | 4:14.283 |
2 | CARPENTER Manon | GBR19930311 | MADISON SARACEN FACTORY TEAM | +2.232 |
3 | NICOLE Myriam | FRA19900208 | COMMENCAL / VALLNORD | +2.566 |
4 | SEAGRAVE Tahnee | GBR19950615 | FMD RACING | +14.045 |
5 | HANNAH Tracey | AUS19880613 | POLYGON UR | +18.221 |
6 | CHARRE Morgane | FRA19900609 | SOLID-REVERSE FACTORY RACING | +19.058 |
7 | WIDMANN Veronika | ITA19930308 | KORAX/LAPIERRE/DIRTYTEAM | +21.668 |
8 | BROWN Casey | CAN19901027 | BERGAMONT HAYES COMPONENTS FACTORY TEAM | +22.595 |
9 | SIEGENTHALER Emilie | SUI19860919 | PIVOT FACTORY DH TEAM | +23.304 |
10 | BARTOVA Jana | CZE19900217 | GHOST RRP | +31.855 |
11 | COLUMB Alanna | NZL19880723 |
| +34.936 |
12 | SALAZAR PALOMO Mariana | ESA19940506 |
| +35.431 |
13 | DE SOUZA OLIVEIRA Luana Maria | BRA19910528 |
| +38.989 |
14 | FARINA Eleonora | ITA19901127 |
| +39.831 |
15 | CAPPELLARI Carina | SUI19911106 | RADON MAGURA FACTORY | +42.784 |
16 | CERNILOGAR Zarja | SLO19891218 | UNIOR TOOLS TEAM | +44.030 |
17 | MOLLOY Tegan | AUS19960118 | KONA FACTORY TEAM | +44.126 |
18 | HRASTNIK Monica | SLO19940607 |
| +45.389 |
19 | RUCKNAGEL Harriet | GER19881011 |
| +46.301 |
20 | CURD Katy | GBR19890427 |
| +47.047 |
21 | CABIROU Marine ยฐ | FRA19970312 |
| +47.632 |
22 | OURDOUILLIE Fiona | FRA19950726 |
| +50.858 |
23 | TYAS Sophie | NZL19941101 |
| +51.784 |
24 | RABEDER Elke | AUT19770526 |
| +57.594 |
25 | RUTZ Lea | SUI19950125 |
| +58.015 |
26 | SANDLER Veronique | NZL19930417 |
| +58.571 |
27 | GRIFFITHS Fionn | GBR19820827 |
| +59.295 |
28 | NOGUEIRA Camila | ARG19930929 |
| +59.495 |
29 | GALLEAN Chloe | FRA19940207 |
| +1:14.545 |
30 | MARTINEZ Carmen | ESP19910804 |
| +1:17.486 |
31 | GREAVES Jessica | GBR19930726 |
| +1:18.319 |
32 | JAGER Linda ยฐ | FRA19970414 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | +1:20.873 |
33 | JULIA BARTHE Blanca | ESP19931012 |
| +1:29.323 |
34 | MONK Amanda | NZL19890909 |
| +1:30.950 |
35 | TANNER Julia | ITA19930817 | KORAX/LAPIERRE/DIRTYTEAM | +2:44.538 |
| MARCELLINI Alia | ITA19910711 |
| DNF |
| ARACIL ALBA Blanca ยฐ | AND19981120 |
| DNF |
Junior Men's Qualifying Results
1 | MARIN TRILLO Alex | ESP19970325 | GIANT FACTORY OFF-ROAD TEAM | 3:52.450 |
2 | CRIMMINS Andrew | AUS19970809 | KONA FACTORY TEAM | +0.118 |
3 | DICKSON Jacob | IRL19971005 | ORANGE DIRT WORLD TEAM, XFUSION | +1.890 |
4 | GREENLAND Laurie | GBR19970218 | TREK WORLD RACING | +2.517 |
5 | PAYET Jordan | FRA19980329 | FRANCE | +2.710 |
6 | REVELLI Loris | ITA19970920 | AB DEVINCI ITALY | +4.173 |
7 | FREW Jackson | AUS19980626 | AUSTRALIA | +4.224 |
8 | COUGOUREUX Benoit | FRA19970928 | TEAM LES GETS BIKEPARK | +6.221 |
9 | SANDRI Connor | NZL19970830 | NEW ZEALAND | +7.160 |
10 | LALY Thibault | FRA19970520 | FRANCE | +7.727 |
11 | STEWART Neil | GBR19970424 | FMD RACING | +8.067 |
12 | MARRY Kevin | FRA19980517 | FRANCE | +9.414 |
13 | FITZGERALD Henry | CAN19980813 | STEVE PEAT SYNDICATE GLOBAL | +11.076 |
14 | WARSHAWSKY Max | AUS19970609 | BERGAMONT HAYES COMPONENTS FACTORY TEAM | +12.010 |
15 | CIRIEGO Maxime | FRA19970124 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | +13.738 |
16 | LONG Yann | FRA19970616 | FRANCE | +16.193 |
17 | CHATANAY Valentin | FRA19980603 | FRANCE | +16.309 |
18 | SORRENTINO Lorenzo | ITA19980523 | ITALY | +18.602 |
19 | MORTON Remy | AUS19980309 | POLYGON UR | +18.916 |
20 | LUCAS Cole | NZL19980810 | NEW ZEALAND | +19.221 |
21 | MASARYK Oskar | SVK19970707 | SLOVAKIA | +19.639 |
22 | FRANSOLET Maxime | BEL19971109 | BELGIUM | +19.892 |
23 | PERICH AVELLI Isaac | ESP19970818 | SPAIN | +20.065 |
24 | CHOMIER Quentin | FRA19970201 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | +20.162 |
25 | POINSOT Tom | FRA19980211 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | +20.731 |
26 | GILLAN Mathew | NZL19981127 | NEW ZEALAND | +20.917 |
27 | PURVIS James | GBR19980407 | GREAT BRITAIN | +21.397 |
28 | ROJCEK Adam | SVK19980907 | SLOVAKIA | +21.400 |
29 | HEAP Elliott | GBR19980106 | CHAIN REACTION CYCLES / PAYPAL | +21.562 |
30 | OXLEY Nial | GBR19970610 | TWOTWO GRAVITY RACING | +22.801 |
31 | MCCUBBING Frazer | GBR19970208 | STEVE PEAT SYNDICATE GLOBAL | +23.506 |
32 | WILLIAMS Nils | GBR19970716 | STEVE PEAT SYNDICATE GLOBAL | +24.065 |
33 | PFEIL Max | GER19980404 | GERMANY | +24.097 |
34 | SWINBANK Bradley | GBR19970630 | STEVE PEAT SYNDICATE GLOBAL | +24.196 |
35 | LEHMANN Janis | SUI19980118 | SWITZERLAND | +25.263 |
36 | MANSON Magnus | CAN19980319 | NORCO FACTORY RACING | +25.863 |
37 | MCGEE Calum | GBR19970119 | GREAT BRITAIN | +28.053 |
38 | MONTANIER Ari | SUI19981024 | SWITZERLAND | +28.495 |
39 | SANDBERG Jonathan | SWE19971211 | SWEDEN | +30.127 |
40 | FREY Frieder | GER19980513 | GERMANY | +30.897 |
41 | BECKERS Sven | GER19970915 | GERMANY | +31.044 |
42 | WOJCIECH Sander | POL19970501 | POLAND | +31.771 |
43 | BERGINC Luka | SLO19970717 | SLOVENIA | +32.401 |
44 | HAVARD Kyle | GBR19980619 | GREAT BRITAIN | +32.609 |
45 | HART Will | GBR19980426 | GREAT BRITAIN | +34.423 |
46 | RUETSCH Constantin | SUI19970603 | SWITZERLAND | +35.785 |
47 | BURGESS Gareth | NZL19970116 | NEW ZEALAND | +36.970 |
48 | SMESTAD Simen | NOR19981219 | NORWAY | +37.784 |
49 | ABBOU Jannik | GER19980625 | GERMANY | +39.204 |
50 | POZZALLO Angelo Renato | ITA19970317 | ITALY | +40.515 |
51 | FRANCARDO Tommaso | ITA19970920 | ITALY | +41.427 |
52 | JAKUBOWSKI Maximilian | GER19970129 | GERMANY | +46.692 |
53 | WARRELL Alistair | GBR19970804 | GREAT BRITAIN | +46.935 |
54 | NEUBAUER Julian | AUT19970110 | AUSTRIA | +53.027 |
55 | VAN HATTUM Rens | NED19970505 | NETHERLANDS | +1:03.195 |
56 | OSMAN Matt | USA19970427 | UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | +1:04.036 |
57 | LANGELAAN VON HEYDEN Carlos | ESP19980115 | SPAIN | +1:07.619 |
58 | SQUIRE Kim | NZL19970517 | NEW ZEALAND | +3:37.026 |
| PFEIFFER Bryan | FRA19970311 | FRANCE | DNF |
| HUMPHRIES Jack | NZL19970225 | NEW ZEALAND | DNF |
| ORIHUELA GONZALEZ Jose Carlos | ESP19981023 | SPAIN | DNF |
| DORRIT Andrew | GBR19970426 | GREAT BRITAIN | DNS |
| FAUVERNIER Kenny | FRA19980809 | ROC VTT OZ-EN-OISANS | DNS |
View replies to: RESULTS: Qualifying from Val di Sole World Cup Downhill
Comments